Bakery Menu

Bakery Menu

Like your Mother used to make - or better is our goal! We use the highest quality ingredients in our baking - imported Guittard Chocolate®, Wholesome Farms® dairy products as well as Clabber Girl®, Pillsbury®, Richs®, and Gold Medal® ingredients delivered fresh daily. An Austrian Pastry Chef is on staff to oversee the production of all our wonderful creations.

Brownies and Cookies

Chocolate chunk, white chocolate macadamia, molasses, mocha crinkle, crescent, white chocolate cherry, butterscotch pecan, cranberry oatmeal, oatmeal raisin, M&M’s®, snickerdoodle, chocolate chip pecan, English toffee, sugar, peanut butter, triple chocolate, shortbread, coconut pecan.

Almond Horn - $2.95 each

Cherry Florentine Bar - $3.25 each

Cookie Monster - $3.50 each

Shaped or themed fondant dipped cookies available upon request.


Rolls

Condiments

Sweet Breads

Banana Nut Bread - $10.50
Poppy Seed Bread - $10.50
Pumpkin Bread - $10.50
Apple Bread with Caramel Glaze - $10.50
Zucchini Bread (seasonal availability) - $10.50

Pies

Pumpkin (seasonal) - $15.00
Fruit (apple, peach or cherry) - $18.00
Chess - $16.00
Fudge - $19.00
Pecan - $19.00
Heavenly Chocolate - $33.00
Jackson - $20.00

Boston Cream - $18.00 Small / $27.00 Large

Cakes

Carrot - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Italian Cream - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
German Chocolate - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Strawberry - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Snickers® - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Red Velvet - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Caramel - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Chocolate Ganache - $26.00 Small / $38.00 Large
Chocolate Bomb - $30.00
Apricot Nectar Bundt - $34.00
Chocolate Amaretto Bundt - $36.00
Mandarin Orange - $38.00
Three Layer Sour Cream Coconut - $39.00
Assorted Cupcakes - $3.00 - $5.00

Also available for special order - sheet cakes, cupcakes, wedding cakes and themed cakes. Call for details.

Entrees

Quiche
Available with Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Spinach, Asparagus, Mushroom, Artichoke, Broccoli, Curry Chicken, Southwest Chicken or any combination.
$27.00 (serves 8-12)

Breakfast Casserole
A savory egg and cheese casserole with your choice of Ham, Bacon, Sausage or Spinach.
$45.00 Full pan (serves 12-15)

Breakfast

Bagel - $2.25 (with cream cheese add $0.50)

Sausage Roll (Mornings only) - $3.25

Ham Roll - $3.25

Muffins - $2.75

Danish / Cinnamon Rolls - $3.75

Drinks

Dry Hot Spiced Tea Mix - $9.00 Pint / $16.00 Quart
Dry Hot Chocolate Mix - $7.00 Pint / $12.00 Quart
Ginger Tea - $6.50 Half Gallon / $12.00 Gallon
Regular Iced Tea - $3.50 Half Gallon / $6.00 Gallon

Gift Baskets

We offer various gift basket options. Please ask one of our staff members for more information.

Specialty Cookies

We offer an extensive selection of shaped, hand-dipped and decorated cookies. Please ask one of our staff members for more information. A minimum of 72 hours advanced notice is needed.

Specialty Desserts

We offer many individual specialty desserts…Chocolate Bomb, Lemon Square, Fruit Tart, Turtle Tart, Snickers® Cheesecake and Éclair, just to name a few. Please come by and browse our bakery case or call to inquire about our daily selection.

Prices subject to change without notice. Please inquire when ordering.

Puffy Muffin Community Hero
Read about it in our
Community News link above.

Tervis Tuesdays!

Every Tuesday 3 - 6 pm

Tervis Tuesdays

Bring in your Puffy Muffin Tervis cup and receive one complimentary fill up of your favorite Puffy Muffin beverage! *Offer is for a limited time only so take advantage now!*